16 Scary Shows to Watch Now That You’ve Finished Stranger Things

This mystery-steeped German export melds the small town paranoia and shadowy agents of Stranger Things with the cosmic dread of Twin Peaks—in fact, Vogue describes the show as "Stranger Things for grown-ups." In season one, a rash of child disappearances plagues the quiet German town. Friends and family search for the missing children, unearthing the town's dark past as well as the wormhole hidden deep in a cave beneath the town's nuclear power plant. Yep, you read that right: Adding to the show's eerie mystery is a mind-bending dose of multiple timelines and sci-fi time travel—making this series a must watch for all genre fans. 

This dark and twisted British horror show from Misfits creator Howard Overman follows two twenty-somethings who must do battle with both inner and outer demons. Amy, a bored bowling alley worker, is suddenly attacked by a sinister creature that only she can see. She's rescued by Raquel, a self-professed demon hunter. Together, Amy and Raquel go toe-to-hellish-toe with a horde of demons and an evil mastermind who plans to bring the world to an end. For all those who enjoy the camaraderie of the Stranger Things gang and the power of friendship to triumph over all kinds of evil, check out Crazyhead.  

Related: The Best Horror Movies on Netflix Right Now 

Look, if you're into Stranger Things chances are high that you're already plugged into the techno-nightmare of Black Mirror. If not, clear your cache and dive into Charlie Brooker's cracked-screen vision of the very near future right now. The latest season hit Netflix in June 2019. 

Stranger Things itself borrows heavily from this 1990s cult favorite. When rational Agent Scully is paired with “true believer” Agent Mulder, weird things, most of which involve aliens and monsters, start happening. If you enjoyed the pairing of Joyce and Hop, Mulder and Scully are right up your alley. Plus, the sinister creatures, psychotic killers, and dark mysteries featured in The X-Files will be sure to give you many a sleepless night.

Related: 15 Little-Known Facts About “The X-Files”

AHS teeters between the absurd and the downright disturbing. While all five seasons are worth watching, Season 2, Asylum, is perhaps the darkest, as well as the most similar to Stranger Things from a tonal perspective. Set in the 1960s, Asylum follows the inner-workings of one of the most harrowing insane asylums in recent television history. Twisted doctors performing gruesome procedures, murder, possession, and kidnapping abound. Do. Not. Watch. This. Alone.

Another 1990s cult classic from which Stranger Things draws inspiration, Twin Peaks begins with the death of high school student Laura Palmer. Laura's shocking end upends the small northwestern town, igniting a mystery that soon grows to cosmic proportions. Co-creators David Lynch and Mark Frost create a dreamy and unsettling atmosphere, one that leaves you constantly on edge. In Twin Peaks, the evil lurking just beneath the mundanity of daily life takes a human form in Bob, one of the most terrifying villains in TV history.

This paranormal import from France breathes new life into the undead genre. Many years after their deaths, the deceased residents of an isolated French alpine village suddenly return to walk among the living. The otherworldly event opens up emotional wounds of the past and fractures the tight-knight community. Meanwhile, strange phenomena send the town into further disarray, from power outages and mysterious marks on the skin of the living and the returned to the inexplicable lowering of the local reservoir's water level. 

If you enjoyed the bad-ass law enforcement and creepy woods-searching of Stranger Things, The Fall might be the next show for you. Whereas the former is set in small town America, and only partially based in reality, the latter is firmly grounded in real-life Northern Ireland. Far from the monster of The Upside Down, The Fall’s monster is a serial killer, hiding in the guise of husband and family man, who brutally attacks and murders women. However, like Officer Hopper, The Fall’s Agent Gibson is a flawed and relatable anti-hero, whose devotion to the bone-chilling case becomes all-encompassing, especially for viewers.

Related: 26 Best Horror Books from the Past 150 Years 

Fringe takes the government conspiracy, child test subject, parallel universe, and superhuman ability elements of Stranger Things and pairs it with the FBI-sponsorship and episodic case-by-case storyline of The X-Files. Though it only ran for five seasons, Fringe has garnered something of a cult following since it went off the air in 2013.

Another short-running show which is sure to gain cult status in the coming years, Penny Dreadful, set in Victorian England, features a rag-tag group of anti-heroes fighting against famous literary monsters from novels like Frankenstein and Dracula. Excellent performances from actors like Eva Green and Rory Kinnear make this show an effective (somewhat)-human drama, while the preponderance of monsters ensures that the scares are constant and intense.

Related: 19 Underrated Horror Movies That You Need to See, According to Reddit 

The executive producer of Hemlock Grove is Eli Roth, so you know it’s going to be scary. Set in the fictional eponymous Pennsylvania town, creepy things are afoot from the get-go. An imposing institute, rumored to be running sinister experiments on human test subjects, is only the start of the town’s dark history. Soon, Hemlock Grove is plagued by horrible murders, and rumors of Werewolf and other inhuman activity.

This Twin Peaks-y show features a small mountain town, where, of course, everything is not as it seems. Secret Service Agent Ethan Burke arrives in Wayward Pines, Idaho, to investigate the disappearance of two fellow agents. After a car accident, Ethan realizes he is unable to leave the town, and unable to contact anyone in the outside world. Furthermore, townspeople are prevented from leaving by an electric fence, as well as the threat of public execution for anyone who tries to escape. Yikes.

Yet another cult classic, The Prisoner is an oft-overlooked gem of the 1960s. After abruptly resigning from his secret agent post, an unnamed agent finds he’s been captured and imprisoned on an island called “The Village.” The Village is governed by a bizarre set of rules, and, of course, not trying to escape is rule number one. A psychedelic 60s atmosphere and a growing sense of paranoia make this show deeply unsettling and disturbing.